Fairfield Should be Naming the Third Train Station
One resident's quest to let the people have a say has gained some momentum
In Kathleen Griffin's idealized version of Fairfield, the people would welcome the third train station with open arms and enter a contest to name the station.
Back when she served on the Representative Town Meeting, on more than one occasion she talked about turning the station on Commerce Drive from being a lightning rod for contentious dialogue to one we could welcome.
More recently, once again a private citizen, Kathleen has brought the notion up anew. She has decided to force the town to have a discussion over whether or not we're comfortable with the current moniker: Metro Center.
"Does the name 'Metro Center' really conjure up an image we want people to have of Fairfield?" Kathleen wrote in a letter to the editor, sent to all the town's newspapers. "Would you like it if the Metro North train schedule read 'Greens Farms, Southport, Fairfield, Metro Center'? I know that I wouldn't. And I think that we as a town, along with our selectmen and our state representatives, need to lobby the state to change it."
Chatting with Kathleen about this last week, she recalled, "I first brought it up to [First Selectman Ken] Flatto some time back. I did it because I think towns are like businesses and products should market themselves and reflect what they want to be about.
"This train station, with a name like Metro Center, does not, I think, reflect how we want people to think about Fairfield. The train station, like the other two, is the first thing seen by people coming into the area."
The 35.5-acre parcel that comprises the station, parking and land for private development is set along Ash Creek and nearly one-third of the space is actually going to be open space, very un-Metro.
"Ken said he'd actually like to do something but Fairfield is not in charge," she continued. The state has control over the naming, and apparently, the Metro Center name came up early and has stuck despite its lack of formal appointment.
"Ken's latest comment was to wait for a new governor and maybe that's the time to try and get naming turned over to the town," Kathleen added. "I don't know if the state cares or does not care. I don't know if the developer cares and if we can force the development to take on the look of the station to work in harmony with the name."
When I asked Flatto about this, he responded, "I have written and asked the DOT to consider a new train station name fitting for our community heritage such as Fairfield Grasmere station, and the state has indicated they are open to suggestions but wish to wait until the station nears completion in mid-late 2011."
The State Department of Transportation did not return repeated calls.
"Fairfield could do a survey and give people a say. Let people voice their opinion," Griffin said. Apparently, the people in town have also given this some thought because she mentioned that three times in the last few weeks people asked her about this issue – all prior to her letter being sent.
And what would she name it? "I like Ash Creek after reading your column [about the Commerce Area study.] It really will become a beautiful part of town with walking trails and green space. We're a beach community, so Ash Creek works."
Given its proximity to the border between Fairfield and Bridgeport, many have considered calling the station Black Rock but Kathleen said, "Ken doesn't want Black Rock because people will think of the Bridgeport area while the station is still in Fairfield. I think the region has cute houses and it's a nice neighborhood within walking distance to train. And there's also Black Rock Turnpike so that would tie things together, but I can understand his town pride coming through."
Since this is a state matter, I asked our three state representatives, all of whom sit on the General Assembly's Transportation Committee. Tom Drew, in whose district the station falls, said, "I support exploring the most advantageous and desirable name possible for the economic benefit of the community in whatever venue(s) may be appropriate."
While Tony Hwang chose not to respond to repeated requests, Kim Fawcett said, "I approached the previous DOT commissioner with Kathleen's idea, and he liked it and agreed that it would be a good way to get the community involved. The state's primary focus right now is to get the station open and servicing commuters, but it is certainly an idea Rep. Drew and I can pursue in 2011. We will need to wait until we have a new governor and a new DOT commissioner to determine how to proceed.
"I love the idea and would be happy to see the commuters who use the station have a say in what the station is called."
Town Attorney Richard Saxl confirmed that the contract between the town, state, and Blackrock Realty, LLC has a placeholder name with the state holding final say. He did remind me, though, that a road is being constructed that will run through the station and the town has control over naming it. Saxl has kiddingly been calling it "Flatto Way" but should Kathleen's quest come to naught, we could always have a street-naming contest.
"It costs us nothing to change the name before signage is printed," Kathleen said. "We should find out what the people want."
true dat
3:47 pm on Monday, October 4, 2010
Agreed. The Metro Center has been a debacle from the start. Having said that, it's coming. Why not get a new name, one that better represents Fairfield and the area. I don't want to live in a town that has a Metro Center. I want Black Rock Train Station or Ash Creek Train Station. Or, better yet, let's sell the rights to the name and pay off some of these ridiculous bonds - GE Train Station, WWF Train Station, or how about, RTC or DTC Train Center?
Jennifer Hochberg
5:15 pm on Monday, October 4, 2010
I like the idea of town residents having input in what to name the new train station....I like the idea of "Grasmere/Ash Creek" myself, since it is in that neck of the woods. Metro Center sounds too generic and "industrial"....
Stephen Krauchick
6:24 pm on Monday, October 4, 2010
Who will be responsible for the sign change on Saturday Night Live LOL??
PQ
7:17 pm on Monday, October 4, 2010
Ash Creek Station- that's got my vote.
Sheryl Santiago
11:39 pm on Monday, October 4, 2010
Since our 2 other stations reflect parts of town they're located in, maybe this one can be called Fairbridge station since it borders both Fairfield and Bridgeport. Otherwise my vote is with Ash Creek, which has such a quaint ring to it.
David Cullen
4:23 pm on Tuesday, October 5, 2010
I vote for "Ash Creek," for all the reasons stated in Bob's column and because it is so evocative.
Black Rock has been part of Bridgeport for 100 years or so, so that should not be the name.
I also hate "Metro Center"-- sounds like an office park-- and I hate any name that has to have "Fairfield grafted onto it.
Look how well "Southport" has worked as a stand-alone name now for, gosh, I bet well over a century.
--David Cullen
RTM District 7
R. Ludlowe
4:39 pm on Tuesday, October 5, 2010
In the spirit of perceived historical blunders, let's call it "Flatto's Folly."
Black Rock Station sounds like a winner to me.
Who cares where Black Rock actually is? (it was originally in Fairfield back in the day if you want to argue history and cartography). Black Rock Turnpike is in Fairfield--I've never heard anyone complain or be confused because of that. And let's face it.... many people that drive to this new station will be taking Black Rock Turnpike to get there.
'Fairfield Avenue' is in the Black Rock part of Bridgeport, after all. Let's just consider it a trade.
Brian
4:52 pm on Tuesday, October 5, 2010
ASH CREEK HANDS DOWN... Black Rock is a horrible suggestion...
R. Ludlowe
4:57 pm on Tuesday, October 5, 2010
No need to get feisty, Brian.
Amy Ulness
5:54 pm on Tuesday, October 5, 2010
It should identify the station as being in Fairfield so people know where they are. If it ends up Ash Creek, I think it should say Fairfield/Ash Creek.
Amy Ulness
R. Ludlowe
4:47 pm on Thursday, October 7, 2010
New Jersey Transit has a station called "Metro Park." I'd tell you where it is, but I can never remember because the name is completely useless.
Russel choate
11:24 am on Thursday, October 14, 2010
Russ
Ash Creek is a polluted mud flat that stinks even at high tide.
Name the station Fairfield East or East Fairfield.
PQ
4:21 pm on Thursday, October 14, 2010
hmm, sounds like East Norwalk. or worse, East New York.
Jeanne
10:18 pm on Thursday, October 14, 2010
Black Rock Station is my first choice. Ash Creek Station would be fine. Metro Center a bad idea.